Elden Ring Nightreign Review – Encapsulating Efficiency

At Gaming News, our journey into The Lands Between has been a continuous exploration of its vast, challenging, and utterly captivating world. The original Elden Ring remains an undisputed masterpiece, a benchmark against which other open-world action RPGs are measured. So, when whispers of Elden Ring Nightreign began to circulate, promising a condensed, run-based roguelite experience with a battle royale-esque closing circle, our initial reaction was one of profound skepticism. Could the intricate depth, the meticulously crafted lore, and the sense of epic progression that defined Elden Ring truly translate into a fast-paced, replayable format? For the first dozen hours of our Nightreign experience, this skepticism lingered, fueled by a nagging feeling that this new iteration might, in fact, dilute the very essence of what made its predecessor so monumental. It felt, at times, like an arcadey abstraction that risked cheapening the rich tapestry of the original. However, as is often the case in The Lands Between, a turning point arrived unceremoniously. Around the twelve-hour mark, a critical mass of accumulated knowledge, honed through repeated attempts and failures, began to coalesce. The disparate elements of Nightreign started to click, and a new appreciation for its unique design philosophy began to blossom.

The Accelerated Journey Through a Familiar Yet Altered Lands Between

Suddenly, the chaotic sprints through Nightreign transformed into orchestrated assaults. We found ourselves, a coordinated trio, anticipating key locations before the in-game day had even fully dawned, meticulously carving efficient pathways across the familiar yet subtly altered landscape of Limbs. Shouted callouts for enemy attack patterns and precise dodge timings became the norm, a testament to the intense real-time strategy that Nightreign demands. This evolution from hesitant exploration to confident execution underscored the game’s core achievement: condensing the arduous, knowledge-acquisition-heavy journey of Elden Ring into intense, approximately 45-minute runs, often culminating in satisfying victory. While this success is not without its considerable caveats, the addictive loop of “just one more run” became an undeniable hallmark of excellence within the roguelite genre.

The setting for these expeditions is Limbs, the iconic starting region of Elden Ring, yet it exists within a divergent timeline. Players are presented with a selection of eight distinct Nightfarers within the Roundtable Hold, each poised to undertake one of eight unique expeditions. The singular objective across all these ventures is survival. This survival is measured over three in-game days, a period punctuated by the need to defeat a multitude of enemies to gain experience, procure vital armaments and consumables, and crucially, overcome the formidable major bosses that punctuate the end of each day. A successful expedition through Limbs culminates in a confrontation with the Nightlord, and the defeat of five such formidable entities is the key to reaching the game’s conclusion. While a narrative framework loosely binds the game’s run-based premise, it remains intentionally barebones, offering just enough context to satisfy those actively seeking it without impeding the core gameplay loop.

The Diverse Arsenal of Nightfarers and Their Impact on Gameplay

While the process of learning and mastering new Nightfarers on the fly can initially present a steep learning curve, potentially impacting the overall success of your trio, each of the eight playable characters brings an undeniably valuable and unique contribution to the team’s strategic arsenal. In our initial hours, we found ourselves gravitating towards the ranged archer, Ironeye, a character whose nimbleness and ranged superiority often proved indispensable for almost every run. However, the appeal of the more resilient Guardian, with his potent invincibility-granting ultimate ability, was also deeply felt. The prospect of mastering the remaining six Nightfarers as we guide newer players through this challenging world is a prospect we eagerly anticipate.

Further incentivizing experimentation and repeated engagement are the special “Remembrance” questlines specifically tailored for each character. These questlines actively encourage players to undertake various runs to complete specific objectives, such as defeating a particular boss to acquire a coveted item. Complementing these are unlockable outfits, adding a visual flair to your journey, and the persistent pursuit of permanently equippable Relics. These Relics offer run-altering buffs and effects, fundamentally shifting the strategic considerations and build possibilities within each expedition. The tangible difference between our performance in the opening hours and our current standing, forty-one hours in after vanquishing every Nightlord, is nothing short of profound. We have transitioned from casually exploring encampments and discovering hidden secrets, much like we would in the original Elden Ring, to a stark realization that every second of wasted time carries the palpable potential for outright ruin. There is simply no room for leisurely exploration, the meticulous search for secrets, or the unhurried experimentation with new combat tactics, at least not if the ultimate goal of defeating the Nightlord by the end of day three is to be achieved, let alone the challenging major bosses that precede this final encounter at the conclusion of days one and two.

Nightreign: The Ultimate Test of Min-Maxing and Indecision

Nightreign could very well be defined as the most accelerated roguelite experience available, an intense lesson in the art of min-maxing that ruthlessly punishes any hint of idle behavior or indecisiveness. In our pre-release experience, coordinating with other members of the press via Discord evolved from casual greetings into a near-silent, focused lock-in moment. As we awaited our Nightfarers to materialize in Limbs, the initial seconds were dedicated to quiet, rapid map scouting. By the time we touched down, our strategy for the first day was already meticulously planned, with immediate considerations for our day two objectives already being formulated, well before our characters even reached level four. It is a brutally fast-paced, demanding experience, amplified by the inherent stress of its mechanics. Yet, there is an undeniable, almost magnetic allure to receiving the distilled essence of a FromSoftware single-player triumph, all within the confines of a mere 45-minute run.

This exhilarating experience, however, can be abruptly shattered by the game’s significant caveats, which can intrude upon enjoyment with the brute force of a Raider Nightfarer’s club. The most predictable and arguably the most detrimental issue is the state of matchmaking. While problematic in a single-player FromSoftware title, it becomes downright unacceptable in Nightreign, a game explicitly designed for three-player cooperative gameplay. Furthermore, despite FromSoftware’s assertions that the game is viable in solo play, the enemy scaling feels so fundamentally unbalanced that it transforms into a Herculean challenge, catering only to the most elite players, or, to put it bluntly, the true masochists. Even when engaging with two other teammates, communicating via voice chat and executing all prescribed strategies, whether employing password matchmaking or direct invite matchmaking, the success of connection felt like a fifty-fifty proposition. When connections inevitably failed, the underlying reason for the failure remained frustratingly opaque. While imperfect matchmaking is an unfortunate reality for any game with a smaller player pool, particularly in pre-launch phases, the fact that none of the other connection systems function with any degree of reliability is deeply concerning. Even when playing with friends, FromSoftware’s notoriously archaic multiplayer infrastructure continues to present an ongoing challenge.

Map Randomness and Unfair Challenges: The Roguelite Lottery

The inherent frustrations of flawed matchmaking are compounded when players are seeded a map that feels like a preordained failed run from the very outset. While there have been instances where we have achieved victory against the odds, despite what we initially perceived as unfavorable circumstances, it is undeniable that certain elements are practically essential for success in each expedition. The first Nightlord, for example, exhibits a significant weakness to holy damage. Ideally, players would encounter multiple holy-aligned camps on their generated map, clearly marked with a distinctive symbol, indicating locations where holy armaments are likely to be found. However, if these specific camps are absent from the map’s layout, the probability of discovering a suitable holy weapon elsewhere diminishes significantly, thereby preventing players from capitalizing on the Nightlord’s primary vulnerability.

While alternative strategies and methods for overcoming such challenges undoubtedly exist, Nightreign is conspicuously direct in its guidance, often explicitly informing players of the most effective tactics against specific Nightlords. It actively encourages the adoption of a particular approach, and it is profoundly disheartening to realize, upon the initial examination of the map, that pursuing this recommended strategy is an unlikely, if not impossible, endeavor. This specific brand of frustration manifests in various ways throughout an expedition. It could be a scarcity of the requisite elemental camps, an inexplicably overtuned world boss (a particular ire is reserved for the Bell-Bearing Hunter), or a dynamically encroaching storm circle that forces players to remain in constant motion for a significant portion of the day. This relentless pressure often necessitates skipping valuable points of interest and even crucial boss encounters simply to ensure survival.

In some instances, our expeditions met an untimely end due to our own strategic missteps. These could range from misinterpreting a boss’s attack patterns, spending too much time meticulously looting an area, or overlooking a vital location such as a church that provides crucial flask upgrades. Each of these failures, however, presented valuable learning opportunities. Conversely, there were an irritatingly frequent number of times when our team’s failure stemmed from Nightreign’s inherent randomness, elements that felt entirely beyond our control and, consequently, maddening. While a degree of random chance is an accepted and even expected characteristic of the roguelite genre, the rigid nature of achieving success in Nightreign leaves virtually no room for deviation or experimentation when unforeseen complications arise. The absence of a “restart expedition” option, forcing players to endure a full failure and return to the Roundtable Hold rather than allowing a tactical reset, is a glaring oversight. This is particularly true when coupled with the persistent matchmaking issues that can further delay the commencement of a new run.

The Enduring Appeal: The Thrill of the Next Run

Despite these persistent frustrations, whether we ultimately completed a run with flying colors, succumbed to a failure that offered valuable lessons, or met an early demise due to an unfavorable twist of fate, the overarching sentiment remained consistent: an unyielding eagerness to embark on another expedition. The potent combination of adrenaline and dopamine that defines a truly exceptional Elden Ring session is present and accounted for throughout Nightreign. The tantalizing knowledge that you are, theoretically, merely 45 minutes away from recapturing those exhilarating feelings provides a powerful, consistent motivator.

Nightreign truly shines when the player is performing at their peak. However, for this potential to be fully realized, FromSoftware’s foray into the roguelite genre must meet players halfway, leaving its more frustrating shortcomings behind at the Roundtable Hold. When the matchmaking functions seamlessly, when the map’s procedural generation offers our trio a genuine fighting chance, and when the encroaching storm does not unfairly disrupt our carefully laid plans, we are genuinely excited to embrace the challenge. The ultimate reward for our persistent efforts is the refined mastery, the hard-won knowledge, and the sheer adrenaline rush that we spent dozens of hours cultivating in the original Elden Ring, now masterfully condensed into a single, potent run. And with every successful expedition, the feeling of accomplishment remains as visceral and glorious as the very first.

Score: 8

About Game Informer’s review system: Gaming News utilizes a comprehensive review system that evaluates games based on multiple criteria including gameplay, narrative, presentation, and overall enjoyment. Our scoring reflects a thorough and nuanced understanding of a game’s strengths and weaknesses, aiming to provide our readers with the most insightful and authoritative reviews in the industry.